Caps Montauk Harbor | Fresh Seafood and Exceptional Service in Montauk, NY

Overview

Cap's Montauk Harbor, located at 448 W Lake Dr in Montauk, NY, offers a standout seafood experience that truly captures the spirit of this coastal town. This seafood restaurant has quickly become a beloved spot for both locals and visitors seeking fresh, expertly prepared dishes in a welcoming atmosphere.

The main highlight at Cap's is undoubtedly their fish and chips, widely praised for being among the best in New York—and possibly beyond. The fish itself is remarkably fresh, with a natural sweetness that speaks to the quality and care behind the sourcing. Its flaky texture pairs perfectly with a batter that strikes the ideal balance: thin, crisp, golden, and light, delivering satisfying crunch without overpowering the delicate fish inside.

Beyond the famed fish and chips, Cap's shines with its diverse seafood offerings. The shellfish pasta is a rich medley of shrimp, scallops, clams, and mussels, cooked just right to preserve brightness and flavor. Other favorites include the creamy clam chowder and perfectly baked oysters, both showcasing the restaurant’s commitment to fresh, ocean-inspired tastes.

Guests frequently highlight the attentive, warm service that complements the food, elevating the entire dining experience. The staff are noted for their friendliness and efficiency—even when the restaurant buzzes with activity. Their dog-friendly approach adds a comfortable, laid-back vibe that suits Montauk's easygoing coastal lifestyle.

Cap's Montauk Harbor is a destination that suits a variety of diners—from couples celebrating special moments to families and seafood enthusiasts craving authentic coastal flavors. Its location in Montauk makes it an ideal stop for those exploring the harbor area or staying nearby. Importantly, it remains open through seasonal shifts when many other local establishments close, ensuring a reliable spot for great seafood year-round.

Whether starting with cocktails and wings during a casual evening or indulging in a full seafood feast, Cap's delivers a satisfying, genuine taste of Montauk’s maritime heritage. The combination of fresh ingredients, thoughtfully prepared dishes, and heartfelt service creates a memorable experience that invites return visits.

What Customers Say

Sofia Chen

Dec 3,2025

5/5

This place serves the best fish and chips in New York — and possibly in the entire U.S.! The portions are generous, and the fish is incredibly fresh. The meat has a natural ocean-sweet flavor with no unpleasant fishy taste. It’s slightly sweet with a delicate, perfectly flaky texture. The batter is outstanding — thin, crispy, and golden, with a crunchy exterior and a soft, juicy interior. The shellfish pasta is also excellent, loaded with shrimp, scallops, clams, and mussels. The clam chowder and baked oysters were delicious as well. The service was warm and attentive, and the staff were wonderfully dog-friendly. Definitely a must-visit spot — and they stay open even when many other places close for the season.

gene carroll

Dec 3,2025

5/5

My wife and I were away for a quick getaway to celebrate our anniversary. We were staying down the block at the Tipperary Inn. After checking in, we wanted to take a walk to check out the Harbour area. On our way back, we stopped at Caps for cocktails and an appetizer. First off, the service was excellent the cocktails and the wings were great. We enjoyed it so much. We went back the next day and did it again. Especially appreciated the wonderful service from Ginger and Sarah.

Delia Brandwood

Dec 3,2025

5/5

Had dinner here! Fish and chips and lobster were outstanding. It was extremely busy but our waitress was so friendly and efficient! Definitely going back there, amazing!!

Stephen Lawrence

Dec 3,2025

5/5

Stumbled upon this new seafood spot when looking for a birthday dinner for our mom — and were so glad we did! The shellfish pasta was outstanding—fresh, flavorful, and perfectly cooked. Service was equally impressive—friendly, attentive, and made us feel right at home. Definitely coming back!!

Alex From ny

Dec 3,2025

5/5

What to start with first? First the service is 12/10 our server seated us immediately and was pleasant the whole time. The food was incredible, the fish was incredibly fresh I recommend asking for the "Fish of the day" and throw that right on a sandwich with fries. Great fish, great food, fast service with a smile. Very impressed.

Betty Lee

Dec 3,2025

5/5

So my husband & I remember this place was Sammy’s from our previous Montauk trips. Never ate there @ those times. We have eaten @ Inlet, Gosmans, Muse, Salivars, Navy Beach, Duryea’s & Tauk. All great restaurants. I noticed that Caps just recently opened in place of Sammy’s & was receiving 5 star reviews for their menu. I was leery that a brand new restaurant was getting such great reviews. Let me tell this restaurant deserves that & more. For our dinner we had the baked oysters which had this whipped cheese foam soo delicious. My husband had the BBQ ribs with sweet potato fries - tender fall off the bone. I couldn’t stop eating the fries! I had the coquille scallop dish - excellent. The next day we caught fish on the fishing boat so we went back & had lunch @ Caps since they will cook what you catch. We chose Francese style which was cooked beautifully. My husband said it was one of the best he ever had. We also had the cooked potato chips with onion dip - definitely a must have . Shout out to Ginger our waitress. And to the live music we had Tuesday night - excellent singer and rest of the group. Sorry didn’t catch their name. We felt that CAPs was better or just as good of any of the Montauk establishments. We’ll be back next time we’re in Montauk!